Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages - CNN.comvar cnnCurrTime=new Date(1374901370000),cnnCurrHour=1,cnnCurrMin=2,cnnCurrDay="Sat",cnnIsIntl=true,clickID=212106,cnn_cvpAdpre="edition.",cnnCVPAdSectionT1="edition.cnn.com_technology_t1",cnnCVPAdSectionInPage="edition.cnn.com_technology_inpage",cnnShareUrl="%2F2013%2F07%2F24%2Ftech%2Fweb%2Fcontroversial-wikipedia-pages%2Findex.html",cnnShareTitle="Wiki%20wars%3A%20The%2010%20most%20controversial%20Wikipedia%20pages",cnnShareDesc="",cnnFirstPub=new Date('Wednesday Jul 24 10:22:36 EDT 2013'),cnnSectionName="tech",sectionName="tech",cnnSubSectionName="tch : news",cnnPageType="Story",cnnBrandingValue="default";cnnPartnerValue="";cnnOmniBranding="",cnnAuthor="Doug Gross, CNN",disqus_category_id=207582,disqus_identifier="/2013/07/24/tech/web/controversial-wikipedia-pages/index.html",disqus_title="Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages",cnn_edtnswtchver="edition",cnnIsStoryPage=true,cnn_metadata = {},cnn_shareconfig = [];cnn_metadata = {section: ["tech","tch : news"],friendly_name: "Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages",template_type: "content",template_type_content: "gallery",business: {cnn: {page: {author: "Doug Gross, CNN",broadcast_franchise: "",video_embed_count: "1",publish_date: "2013/07/24",photo_gallery: "Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages"},video: {video_player: ""}}},user: {authenticated: "",segment: {age: "",zip: "",gender: ""}}};if (typeof(cnnOmniPartner) !== "undefined") {if (cnn_metadata.template_type_content === "") {cnn_metadata.template_type_content = "partner";}}var photo_gallery = "Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages";if(typeof CNN==='undefined'){var CNN=Class.create();}CNN.expandableMap=[''];function _loginOptions(){};var disqus_url=(typeof disqus_identifier!=='undefined') ? 'http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/24/tech/web/controversial-wikipedia-pages/index.html' : 'http://www.cnn.com'+location.pathname;cnnad_newTileIDGroup(['970x66_top','300x250_rgt','300x250_rgt2','336x280_rgt','336x850_rgt','300x150_rgt','728x90_top','728x90_bot','BG_Skin','120x90_bot1','120x90_bot2','120x90_bot3']);cnnad_newTileIDGroup(['607x95_adlinks','336x280_adlinks']);

EDITION: INTERNATIONAL U.S. MÉXICO ARABIC TV: CNNi CNN en Español Set edition preference Sign up Log in Home Video World U.S. Africa Asia Europe Latin America Middle East Business World Sport Entertainment Tech Travel iReport SHARE THISPrintEmailMore sharingRedditStumbleUponDelicious/* push in config for this share instance */cnn_shareconfig.push({"id" : "cnn_sharebar1","url" : "http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/24/tech/web/controversial-wikipedia-pages/index.html","title" : "Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages"});Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages

By
Doug Gross, CNNJuly 24, 2013 -- Updated 1518 GMT (2318 HKT) | Filed under: Webif (typeof cnnArticleGallery=="undefined"){var cnnArticleGallery={};if(typeof cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList=="undefined"){cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList=[];}}var expGalleryPT00=new ArticleExpandableGallery();expGalleryPT00.setImageCount(11);expGalleryPT00.setAdsRefreshCount(3);//cnn_adbptrackpgalimg("The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages", 1);.cnn_html_slideshow_metadata > .cnn_html_media_utility::before{color:red;content:'>>';font-size:9px;line-height:12px;padding-right:1px}.cnnstrylccimg640{margin:0 27px 14px 0}.captionText{filter:alpha(opacity=100);opacity:1}.cnn_html_slideshow_media_caption a,.cnn_html_slideshow_media_caption a:visited,.cnn_html_slideshow_media_caption a:link,.captionText a,.captionText a:visited,.captiontext a:link{color:#004276;outline:medium none}.cnnVerticalGalleryPhoto{margin:0 auto;padding-right:68px;width:270px}

Oxford University researchers took a look at Wikipedia's most controversial pages, studying which ones saw the most instances where an editor changed something, then someone changed it back to its previous form. Here are their top 10.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":true,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":1,"title":"The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages"}

The polarizing 43rd U.S. president topped the list. The busiest period of editing was in the days before Bush's 2004 re-election. It got so bad that Wikipedia froze Bush's page, as well as that of Democratic rival John Kerry.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":2,"title":"1. George W. Bush"}

Chaos on a page about anarchism? Who would have thought? Many changes on the page about the political philosophy -- which opposes the control of official government states -- add or clean up loaded language.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":3,"title":"2. Anarchism"}

The prophet of Islam (CNN's style is "Mohammed") is no doubt targeted in some cases because of anti-Islamic sentiments. But a big number of the changes on the page come because of disputes about the dates of significant events in his life.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":4,"title":"3. Muhammad"}

No, we didn't see a pro wrestling page making the list either. But with an ever-changing roster and the titles, descriptions and even names of its performers constantly changing, it makes sense that it would be among the site's most frequently tweaked pages.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":5,"title":"4. List of WWE personnel"}

Mainstream science is pretty much in lockstep over the reality of climate change. But a handful of vocal dissenters, and the political nature of the global-warming debate, keep its page in flux.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":6,"title":"5. Global warming"}

Circumcision has become a controversial medical procedure in some circles. Some Wiki editors have been removing positive information about it, while others delete negative reports.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":7,"title":"6. Circumcision"}

Hey, it's a big country. On its expansive page -- which includes sections on history, population, government, demographics and more -- there are a lot of moving parts, as well as lots of things to disagree over.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":8,"title":"7. The United States"}

There's the obvious controversy that comes from most religious discussions here, as well as frequent tweaking of terminology, abbreviations and other details.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":9,"title":"8. Jesus"}

It's pretty well documented that there are systemic differences on IQ tests among various racial and ethnic groups. And yes, there are opposing views among Wikipedia editors about the role genetic factors play in those differences.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":10,"title":"9. Race and intelligence"}

Again, almost any religion produces strong differing views. On this page, it's usually references to the fine points of Christian doctrine that are tweaked, and retweaked, and tweaked again.cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList.length]={"currentPicture":false,"x":0,"y":0,"pos":11,"title":"10. Christianity"}HIDE CAPTIONThe 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages1. George W. Bush2. Anarchism3. Muhammad4. List of WWE personnel5. Global warming6. Circumcision7. The United States8. Jesus9. Race and intelligence10. Christianity<<<

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11>>>Event.observe(window,'load',function(){if(typeof(cnn_adbptrackpgalimg) == 'function' && typeof(cnnArticleGallery) != 'undefined'){cnn_adbptrackpgalimg(cnnArticleGallery.currentImageList[0].image,"Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages");}});
STORY HIGHLIGHTSGeorge W. Bush tops list of most controversial English-language Wiki pagesAnalysis looked at Wikipedia pages with most frequent changesPolitics and religions dominate the top 10A pro wrestling page also made the list
(CNN) -- They've long been considered topics that aren't polite to discuss at the dinner table. As it turns out, politics and religion can get touchy on Wikipedia as well.
The two topics dominated a list of the most controversial pages on the crowdsourced Web encyclopedia.Topping the English-language version of the list? Former President George W. Bush.To determine the most controversial pages, researchers from Oxford University looked at their number of "reverts" -- instances in which an editor changes something on a page, only to have someone else come along and change it back to the previous wording.var currExpandable="expand15";if(typeof CNN.expandableMap==='object'){CNN.expandableMap.push(currExpandable);}var mObj={};mObj.type='video';mObj.contentId='';mObj.source='business/2012/12/05/qmb-wikipedia-jimmy-wales-intv.cnn';mObj.videoSource='CNN';mObj.videoSourceUrl='http://business.blogs.cnn.com/category/quest-means-business/';mObj.lgImage="C:\Program Files\Auto Blog Samurai\data\CNN\Technology\121205075234-qmb-wikipedia-jimmy-wales-intv-00022712-story-body.jpg";mObj.lgImageX=300;mObj.lgImageY=169;mObj.origImageX="214";mObj.origImageY="120";mObj.contentType='video';CNN.expElements.expand15Store=mObj;


Wikipedia asks for your cashAlongside Bush, the political philosophy of anarchism made the list. So did global warming and the United States -- two topics that, while not exclusively political, certainly have political elements.As for religion, Mohammed, Jesus and Christianity were all among the top 10.Circumcision and "race and intelligence," both with obvious controversy attached, made the list, alongside a possibly more surprising page: a list of professional wrestlers on the roster of World Wrestling Entertainment.The authors of the study, which will be part of an upcoming book, said that on a site as expansive and ambitious as Wikipedia, disagreements are bound to happen."While the common aim in the collaboration is clear, unavoidably differences in opinions and views occur, leading to controversies," they wrote. "Clearly, there is a positive role of the conflicts: if they can be resolved in a consensus, the resulting product will better reflect the state of the art than without fighting them out."However, there are examples, where no hope for a consensus seems in sight -- then the struggle strongly limits efficiency."The guiding principle behind Wikipedia, which launched in 2001, is cooperation. The thinking is that with a team of volunteer editors spanning the globe, rough edges will eventually be smoothed out and good information will triumph over falsehoods and misinterpretations.With more than 470 million unique visitors monthly, Wikipedia is one of the most-visited sites on the Web. It's written and edited collaboratively by Internet volunteers, most of them anonymous. According to its own pages, the site has more than 77,000 active contributors working on more than 22 million articles in 285 languages.By default, any change that an editor makes on the site is published immediately, subject to cleaning up by editors who come afterward.But disagreements, even among well-meaning editors, are bound to happen and, over the years, Wikipedia has adopted rules to deal with them.On the English-language version, only registered users may create new articles. And certain controversial pages get "protection" -- either full protection, which means they can only be edited by administrators, or semi-protection, under which they can only be edited by logged-in users whose accounts have been verified.When pages become home to "edit wars," as the entries for Bush and Democratic rival John Kerry did during the 2004 election, they may be given temporary protection by administrators.On the English-language version of the site, sweeping issues such as religion dominated the most-disputed list. But the study's authors noted that with most other languages, more local or regional topics prevailed."The English Wikipedia, in particular, occupies a unique role," they wrote. "The language's status as a 'lingua franca' (a widely used working language) means that English Wikipedia ends up being edited by a broad community beyond simply (those) that have the language as a mother tongue."In German, the page on Croatia was the most controversial, with Adolf Hitler, Scientology and Austrian philosopher Rudolf Steiner making the top 10. Socialist politician Segolene Royal topped the French list (followed, curiously, by UFOs) and "Gypsy crime" topped the Hungarian list.In an interesting look at cultural interests, five of the 10 most disputed pages in Spanish were those of soccer teams -- Club America, Athletic Bilbao, Newell's Old Boys, FC Barcelona and Alianza Lima.0Comments »SHARE THISPrintEmailMore sharingRedditStumbleUponDelicious/* push in config for this share instance */cnn_shareconfig.push({"id" : "cnn_sharebar2","url" : "http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/24/tech/web/controversial-wikipedia-pages/index.html","title" : "Wiki wars: The 10 most controversial Wikipedia pages"});var OB_permalink='http://edition.cnn.com'+location.pathname;var OB_langJS='http://widgets.outbrain.com/lang_en.js';var OB_widgetId='AR_1';var OB_Template="cnnedition";if (typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined'){OutbrainStart();}else{var OB_Script=true;var str="cnnad_createAd("730968","http://ads.cnn.com/html.ng/site=cnn_international&cnn_intl_pagetype=mmst&cnn_intl_position=607x95_adlinks&cnn_intl_rollup=technology&page.allowcompete=no¶ms.styles=fs","95","607");cnnad_registerSpace(730968,607,95);cnnad_createAd("834503","http://ads.cnn.com/html.ng/site=cnn_international&cnn_intl_pagetype=mmst&cnn_intl_position=336x850_rgt&cnn_intl_rollup=technology&page.allowcompete=no¶ms.styles=fs","850","336");cnnad_registerSpace(834503,336,850);

.cnn_strycrcntrnwsp .cnn_mtpmore { padding:10px 0px 1px 0px; }.cnn_stryccnwsp2 .cnn_stryccnwsp3 { width:100% }Most PopularToday's five most popular storiesAriel Castro agrees to plea deal to avoid death penaltyGoogle introduces $35 device that streams video to your TVHitler's Eagle's Nest and other tyrants' lairs open to all80 dead in Spain crash; video catches train's final momentsFDA proposes new safety rules on imported food

var cnn_oburlStr = location.pathname + '';cnn_oburlStr = (cnn_oburlStr.indexOf('?') > -1) ? cnn_oburlStr.substr(0, cnn_oburlStr.indexOf('?')) : cnn_oburlStr;var OB_permalink= 'http://edition.cnn.com' + cnn_oburlStr;var OB_Template="cnnedition";var OB_widgetId= 'VR_1';var OB_langJS ='http://widgets.outbrain.com/lang_en.js';if ( typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined' ) {OutbrainStart();} else {var OB_Script = true;var str = "var OB_Template="cnnedition";var OB_widgetId= 'SB_2';var OB_langJS ='http://widgets.outbrain.com/lang_en.js';if ( typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined' ) {OutbrainStart();} else {var OB_Script = true;var str = ".OB_SB_1, .OB_SB_2 { padding:0px; }#outbrain_container_1_stripBox .strip-like, #outbrain_container_2_stripBox .strip-like { font-size:18px; }#ob_strip_container_rel_1_stripBox { }#ob_strip_container_rel_1_stripBox .item-container, #ob_strip_container_rel_2_stripBox .item-container { padding-top:8px;border-top:1px solid #E5E5E5; }cnnad_createAd("578387","http://ads.cnn.com/html.ng/site=cnn_international&cnn_intl_pagetype=mmst&cnn_intl_position=300x150_rgt&cnn_intl_rollup=technology&page.allowcompete=no¶ms.styles=fs","150","300");cnnad_registerSpace(578387,300,150);

cnnad_createAd("625961","http://ads.cnn.com/html.ng/site=cnn_international&cnn_intl_pagetype=mmst&cnn_intl_position=336x280_adlinks&cnn_intl_rollup=technology&page.allowcompete=no¶ms.styles=fs","280","336");cnnad_registerSpace(625961,336,280);
Loading weather data ...

Home | Video | World | U.S. | Africa | Asia | Europe | Latin America | Middle East | Business | World Sport | Entertainment | Tech | Travel | iReport Tools & Widgets | RSS | Podcasts | Blogs | CNN Mobile | My Profile | E-mail Alerts | CNN Shop | Site map | CNN Partner Hotels CNN en ESPAÑOL | CNN Chile | CNN México | ??????? | ??? | Türkçe

© 2013 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of service | Privacy guidelines | Ad choices

| Advertise with us | License our content | About us | Contact us | Work for us | Help CNN TV | HLN | Transcripts cnnad_ugsync(); var cnn_edtnswtchver="edition"; msQueueManager.init('requestFrame',ms_blankURL); if(ms_isLoggedIn()){ CNN_setCookie('CNN_member',true,854400,'/',document.domain); } var jsmd=_jsmd.init(),pageURL=location.href.toLowerCase();if (pageURL.indexOf("/.element/ssi/ads.iframes/")==-1&&pageURL.indexOf("/doubleclick/dartiframe.html")==-1&&pageURL.indexOf("/search/")==-1){if (_jsmd.plugin.gQuery("refresh")){jsmd.trackMetrics("dynamic-autoRefresh","autorefresh","cnn-autorefresh");} else if (_jsmd.plugin.gQuery("is_LR")){} else if (cnn_metadata.template_type_content!="gallery"){jsmd.send();}}/*globals CNN_CB, cnnsocial, cnnzite_mod, sectionName *//* configure apis to load and specify their callbacks */cnnsocial.setapiconfig([{'site' : 'facebook','success' : function() {/* trigger connect-cnnsocial.js calls */window.cnn_fbAsyncInit();}},{ 'site' : 'twitter' }]);/* add the multiple config instance for sharebars */cnnsocial.share.setconfig(cnn_shareconfig);$j(document).ready(function () {'use strict';loadChartbeat("tech", "Doug Gross, CNN");CNN.initFlipperTicker();/* initialize cnnsocial */cnnsocial.init();});
View the original article here